"I can't believe you lived you went to Berkeley and never ate at Top Dog!" was repeated emphatically by a guy I had just met at the Patel sibling party (which btw, kudos to Nilay for his incredible grilled cedar plank salmon). I didn't really have a good explanation - I was a vegetarian for a good many years while living in Berkeley, I never paid attention, I'm not quite sure why not.
So while walking to the Cal football game a few days ago, Top Dog on Durant became a destination point, for lunch and in part, so I could try to figure out the appeal. I had chicken apple, it was served on a slightly stale bun, and frankly, after eating the dog and throwing away about a quarter of the bun, I realized I didn't miss out on much. Maybe the experience is different on a non-football day, when Top Dog's mission is to make good dogs, not simply feed the hungry masses passing by on their way to the stadium. But I have to say, the dogs we bbq every Thursday at kickball are better.
On the other hand, I had an excellent margharita pizza, and of course, beer, at Jupiter. It's a great bar on Shattuck, near the BART station, that I used to frequent after I graduated from college. I closed down the bar several times (Marty, if you're out there, I won't forget) and I celebrated my 27th? 28th? birthday at Jupiter...I'll never how excited I became when the guy I had a crush on appeared at Jupiter to help me celebrate my birthday...
Did I miss anything by not eating at Top Dog? NO. I frequented other Berkeley places, some of which still exist, others of which are now legend. Barneys. Zachary's. Zona Rosa. Raleighs. The salad places on both sides of Raleighs, one which was really popular, but the other was so much better, Coffee Source maybe? The Japanese Place, which moved from Durant to Durant Alley. Steve's Korean BBQ, with a giant rice cooker. Togo's. Noah's. Yogurt Park. Campus dining. SO I can't quite remember what happened ten years ago...but I can try, right?
Maybe I'll try Top Dog again. But I have a feeling, Top Dog is good because it is cheap for college students who just don't have a lot of $$ for food after writing checks to "the UC Regents". Even when the monetary situation improves with real jobs, Top Dog plays on nostalgia, allowing one to relive the memories of college. I'm glad I finally got there....at least now, I can say I ate at Top Dog.